Store Credit Cards: To Open or Not to Open
Store credit cards have long been a tempting offer at checkout — they usually come with an instant discount, exclusive perks, and easy approval. But are store credit cards bad for your credit? The answer isn’t black and white. While they can be a useful tool for some, they also come with risks that could harm your credit if not managed properly.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of store credit cards, how they compare to traditional credit cards, and whether they’re the right choice for you.
What are store credit cards?
Store credit cards come in two forms:
- Closed-loop credit cards – These can only be used at a specific retailer (e.g., a Target RedCard or an Amazon Store Card).
- Open-loop credit cards – These carry a retailer’s branding but can be used anywhere that accepts the card’s payment network (e.g., a Capital One Walmart Rewards Card that works anywhere Mastercard is accepted).
While both types offer rewards and discounts at their respective stores, closed-loop cards tend to have lower credit limits and higher interest rates.
Pros and cons of store credit cards
What are the pros of store credit cards?
Store credit cards remain popular for several reasons:
- Easier approval – They’re often easier to qualify for, making them attractive to individuals with limited or poor credit histories.
- Instant discounts and perks – Many retailers offer an immediate discount on your first purchase and ongoing rewards for store loyalty.
- Special financing offers – Some store cards provide deferred interest financing on large purchases—though this can be risky if not paid off in time.
For frequent shoppers of a particular store, these benefits can make a store credit card worth considering.
What are the cons of store credit cards?
While store credit cards can offer short-term benefits, they also come with major pitfalls:
- High interest rates – Many store cards have APRs over 25%, making it costly to carry a balance. If you don’t pay off your purchases in full, interest charges can add up quickly.
- Low credit limits – Store credit cards often come with lower credit limits (often between $200 and $300), which can make it easy to max out the card and hurt your credit utilization ratio (a key factor in your credit score).
- Limited use – A closed-loop credit card may lock you into shopping at one retailer, potentially discouraging you from price shopping for better deals elsewhere.
- Deferred interest traps – Many store cards offer "0% interest for 12 months" promotions, but if you don’t pay the full balance by the end of the promotional period, you may be hit with retroactive interest on the original purchase amount.
Are store credit cards bad for your credit?
The impact of a store credit card on your credit depends entirely on how you use it. Here’s how store credit cards can both help and hurt your credit score:
How they can help your credit
Credit building – If you’re new to credit, using a store credit card responsibly (paying on time and keeping balances low) can help establish a positive credit history.
On-time payments – Payment history is the biggest factor in your credit score, and store credit cards report to credit bureaus just like traditional credit cards.
Credit mix – Having different types of credit (e.g., a store card in addition to a traditional credit card or a loan) can slightly boost your credit score.
How they can hurt your credit
Hard inquiries – Applying for a store credit card results in a hard credit inquiry, which can temporarily lower your score.
High utilization – Low credit limits make it easy to rack up a high balance relative to your available credit, which can negatively impact your score.
Account age – If you open and close store cards frequently, it can shorten your average account age, another factor in your credit score.
Store credit cards vs. Secured credit cards: which is better for building credit?
If you’re looking for a way to build credit, store credit cards aren’t your only option. A secured credit card may be a better alternative.
| Store Credit Card | Secured Credit Card | |
|---|---|---|
| Approval requirements | Easy to get, even with poor credit | Requires a security deposit but there's typically no credit requirement |
| Interest rates | Typically high (25%+ APR) | Often lower than store cards |
| Credit limit | Usually low ($200-$300) | Based on deposit amount, which is refunded once card is converted to a regular credit account |
| Can it be used anywhere? | Closed-loop cards only work at one store | Yes, works like a traditional credit card |
| Does it provide a path to traditional credit? | Does not typically convert to a standard card | Can convert to an unsecured card after responsible use |
If your goal is simply to build or improve credit, a secured credit card is often a safer, more flexible choice.
How to use store credit cards responsibly
If you decide to open a store credit card, follow these best practices to minimize risks:
- Pay your balance in full – Avoid interest charges by paying off your balance every month.
- Keep your credit utilization low – Try not to use more than 30% of your credit limit to protect your credit score.
- Only open cards you’ll use – Don’t open multiple store cards just for discounts—they can hurt your credit if you don’t manage them properly.
- Understand the fine print – Be cautious of deferred interest promotions and other hidden fees.
Are you struggling with credit card debt? We can help
If you’re juggling multiple store credit cards or struggling with high-interest debt, MMI has debt relief solutions that can save you time and money. See how you can Do Debt Differently with MMI and repay debt 7x faster than doing it alone.
